However, the argument that repealing glasssteagall caused the financial. Moving beyond calls for a new glasssteagall brookings institution. Indexdigest of the federal reserve act and amendments board of governors of fed res system 1918. The glasssteagall act effectively separated commercial banking from investment banking and created the federal deposit insurance corporation, among other things. In this volume, benston revisits the historical record and reconsiders the case for appeal. A legal and policy analysis congressional research service summary the phrase glass steagall generally refers to the separation of commercial banking from investment banking. Take for example the poster child of the end of glass steagall. Banking act of 1933 glasssteagall federal reserve history. Glass steagall refers to four sections of the banking act of 1933, which were set to remedy the absolute power of the financial sector by creating a firewall between commercial and investment banking.
The merger of citicorp, a bank, and travelers group, a financial conglomerate, was announced in 1998 before glass steagall was repealed. Benstons book is a major intellectual contribution to the ongoing debate. Steagall act, when in fact barriers to merging with or acquiring banks in other states were removed by the riegle. Financial dynasties and the triumph of the small investor new york. The separation of commercial and investment banking. The repeal of glass steagall specifically, and the orgy of financial deregulation more generally, has created the subprime mortgage, banking, and stock market crises of. Continue reading rewriting the history of the financial crises and the repeal of glass steagall.
Readers of the buzz think its a good idea but are skeptical regulation will pass congress. Aftermath of the repeal of the glasssteagall act wikipedia. Banking act of 1933 that limited commercial bank securities activities and affiliations within commercial banks and securities firms. The big banks i mean, once we repealed glass steagall back in the late 1999s, the big banks, the six of them, went from controlling, what, the equivalent of 15 percent of our gdp to now 65. The long demise of glass steagall a chronology tracing the life of the glass steagall act, from its passage in 1933 to its death throes in the 1990s, and how citigroups sandy weill dealt the.
Related to the making the connection an editorial in the wall street joumal argues that. It analyzes the content of four sections of the banking act of 1933, which came to be known as glass steagall, and describes the content of the legislative text and its limitsloopholes. At the time, industry lobbyists argued that this modern experiment in deregulation would bring greater stability and competitiveness to the financial services industry. Some economists point to the repeal of the glass steagall act as a key factor leading to the housing market bubble and subsequent great recession, the financial crisis of. By the time clinton signed the financial services modernization act, commonly known as grammleachbliley, repealing the key components of glass steagall. Banking act of 1933, commonly called glass steagall this is a good place to start. And he actively supported the 1999 grammleachbliley act that repealed the new dealera glass steagall act, which separated commercial and investment banking. Indexdigest of the federal reserve act and amendments the act of december 23, 19 1915. Traders crowd the sidewalks outside the new york stock exchange on the day of the 1929 market crash. For broader coverage of glass steagall, including its history, similar legislation, regulatory and industry reactions, and repeal, see the main article. Out of all the books about the crisis in 2008, the ones i felt were most enjoyable and.
Glass steagall introduced banking reforms that were. Designed to prevent the kinds of bank failures that resulted from the crash of 1929 and the great depression that followed, the act made it illegal for commercial banks to engage in investment banking, and for investment. The law was passed as part of fdrs new deal programs that. The glasssteagall act, also known as the banking act of 1933 48 stat. The glasssteagall legislation describes four provisions of the united states banking act of 1933 separating commercial and investment banking. The term glass steagall act usually refers to four provisions of the u. The 1933 passage of the glass steagall act by congress has profoundly effected the way banking has been conducted in the united states. Glass steagall glasssteagall banking act of 1933 franklin d roosevelt fdr was the 32nd american president who served in office from march 4, 1933 to april 12, 1945. Even banks growth is blamed on the repeal of the glass. Congressional efforts to repeal the glass steagall act referred to those four.
Its all politics the financial regulatory law became a big part of the democratic debate tuesday night. The 1999 grammleachbliley essentially repealed the glass steagall act, which was signed into law by president franklin d. Congressional efforts to reinstate glasssteagall have not been successful. A bill to reduce risks to the financial system by limiting banks ability to engage in certain risky activities and limiting conflicts of interest, to reinstate certain glass steagall act protections that were repealed by the grammleachbliley act, and for other purposes. Glass steagall trumpclinton act, wall street journal, july 28, 2016. The glass steagall act served this country incredibly well for 66 years until wall street lobbyists finally forced its repeal in 1999. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. The glasssteagall act of 1933, which has been partially repealed, prevented commercial banks from making risky investments with customer. Introduced in senate 04062017 21st century glasssteagall act of 2017. Practical banking, with a survey of the federal reserve act 1915.
The glasssteagall act of 1933, which has been partially repealed, prevented commercial banks from making risky investments with. At the time of the repeal it did not appear likely to have negative consequences, and it had the likely positive consequence of enabling lenders to participate directly in the lucrative tranching of securities as investments. Designed to prevent the kinds of bank failures that resulted from the crash of 1929 and the great depression that followed, the act made it illegal for commercial banks to engage in investment banking, and for investment banks to engage in commercial banking. As former federal reserve chairman ben bernanke pointed out in his excellent book the courage to act, if glass steagall had been in effect in 2008 when the financial system was on the brink.
The glass steagall law was enacted as a key reform in 1933, the depths of the great depression, in the overall effort to prevent the corruptions and abuses of the 1920s from enabling such a dire result again. Many wise people are now recognizing that the repeal of glasssteagall was one of the few saving graces of the current crisis. Books by language additional collections indic manuscripts. The origins of the deep state in north america part. For every right wing type who blames the community reinvestment act for the 2008 financial crisis youll find left wing types who blame the the repeal of glass steagall in 1999 for the same. It was one of the most widely debated legislative initiatives before being signed into law by president franklin d. Learn more about this act using the lesson called the glasssteagall act. The glass steagall legislation was enacted by the united states congress in 1933 as part of the 1933 banking act, amended as part of the 1935 banking act, and most of it was repealed in 1999 by the grammleachbliley act glba. Did glass steagall cause the 2008 financial crisis. A 3 part masterpiece article, essential for proper understanding of the deep state aka british system. It worked because of its simplicity and its threat of five years of jail time for those who violated its key provisions. The glass steagall separation of investment and deposit banking was generally repealed by the grammleachbliley act of 1999, during the administration of bill clinton. The glasssteagall act, explained the simple dollar. However, in response to the financial crisis of 2008, there has been much discussion of whether repeal was a mistake and whether some or all of its restrictions should be.
The glasssteagall act of 1933 separated risky investment banking activity from depositors funds. The country was in the very depths of the great depression, and there were bank runs, as more than 5,000 banks went out of business. Banking act of 1933, commonly called glass steagall and, if you are looking for some more polemic material. The article 1933 banking act describes the entire law, including the legislative history of. One of my firms clients was the securities industry association sia, which pushed the agenda of the investment banks in washington and new york and fought to preserve glass steagall in the 1980s. The move repealed the glass steagall act of 1933, a set of reforms responsible for the longest crisisfree period in u. Established in 1933 and repealed in 1999, the glasssteagall act separated commercial banking and investment banking. Congressional efforts to repeal the glasssteagall act, referring to those four. Congress effected a separation of commercial and investment banking through four sections of the banking act of 1933sections 16, 20, 21. In theory, by taking wall street out of the equation, banks couldnt invest in securities with their. It established the federal deposit insurance corporation fdic and included other banking reforms, and placed legal restrictions on combined banking and financial service firms. Repealing glass steagall in the grammleachbliley act of 1999 was a signature victory of the conservative movements deregulatory agenda, which was also supported by president bill clinton.
What is the argument in favor of believing that repealing. Identify the event that caused the creation of glass steagall determine how people. If these efforts were successful, it would result in a massive reorganization of the banking industry. The grahamleachbliley act that president clinton signed had everything to do with the crisis. Glasssteagall was one of the many necessary measures taken by franklin delano roosevelt. This bill amends the federal deposit insurance act, the bank holding company act of 1956, the home owners loan act, the international banking act of 1978. Lets thank president clinton and phil gramm for that wise bit of deregulation. The following potted history of the law, however, is all too typical. Dealbook takes a look at the state of banking 10 years after the repeal of the glasssteagall act of 1933, which had separated commercial and. Now that youve read the above arguments, tell us who is most to blame for todays mess. The article 1933 banking act describes the entire law, including the legislative history of the provisions covered herein as for the glass steagall act of 1932, the common name comes from the names of the congressional sponsors, senator carter. Congress in 1933 as the banking act, which prohibited commercial banks from participating in the investment banking business.
The 1933 glass steagall act prohibited commercial banks from conducting investment banking activities, and vice versa, for over 60 years. The glasssteagall act was enacted in 1933 in response to banking. Until the 1970s, glass steagall was pretty much the law of the land. Thus, if congress adopted silvers suggestions for complete repeal, the public and the banking. One of the important events during his presidency was passing the second glass steagall act, also known as the banking act of 1933. Ironically, if she has her way in the future and investment banking is once again separated from commercial banking, the biggest beneficiary of a new glass steagall law would be the wall street. The glasssteagall act, part of the banking act of 1933, was landmark. Some economists point to the repeal of the glass steagall act as a key factor leading to the housing market bubble and subsequent great recession. Im not so sure about repealing the glass steagall act. Its protections and restrictions had also been chipped away during most of its existence by lenient regulatory interpretations and use of loopholes. What books or articles should i read to understand the. The glass steagall act commonly refers to the banking act of 1933, the law that separated commercial and investment banking in the u. Repeal would, in effect, extend the protection of deposit insurance to investment banks and other risky entities. The glasssteagall act effectively separated commercial banking from.
1243 908 329 1470 320 1268 1271 1132 1122 665 494 270 46 831 1505 765 1183 1385 1324 1039 70 1364 226 1067 857 1244 1168 1272 1319 1429 479